born at 321.89 PPM CO2

Credit is due to René Magritte, Man Ray, Salvador Dalí and Leonora Carrington, whose extraordinary work has inspired many of the images featured throughout this blog.

Saturday, 8 November 2025

LEST WE FORGET

PTE MONK - ALFRED - 53648 - 1/19th London Regiment - link - more like this - link - more like this - link

(GUF) DIGITAL OVERDOSE

On paper, a digital ID sounds like a godsend - making banking, booking and buying much smoother/easier. Everyone should have the right to one if they choose.

But choice is the key word. Because the same 'gateway app' that promises convenience could just as easily become a gatekeeper — deciding who gets to bank, shop or even claim benefits.

We must defend the right to live and trade offline. Cash isn’t just old-fashioned; it’s freedom with a face value. Passports and driving licences already prove who we are when needed, we simply don’t need a digital leash - link

My concern is simple; give too much control to a centralised ID system, and dissent stops being inconvenient, it becomes impossible.

On 15 July 2025, China launched the National Network Identity Authentication - a system requiring citizens to verify their identity via official ID and facial recognition, linked to their mobile number. Officially, it’s voluntary; in practice, critics say it will become unavoidable.

The system replaces existing real-name and SIM registration requirements, meaning the police and cyber regulators now have unified access to every online identity. As in the UK, authorities claim it helps protect personal data and reduce fraud. Critics, however see it as extending state oversight over everything from online shopping to browsing history, travel and communication.

Those critics haven’t gone unpunished. Law professors Lao Dongyan and Shen Kui, who publicly challenged the plan had their social media accounts muted and posts censored. Lao’s account was silenced for 90 days after criticising the system. The chilling effect is real, tie every digital act to a single ID and dissent becomes traceable.

China’s long-standing Social Credit System already publicly labels 'untrustworthy' citizens; naming and shaming them online to 'encourage moral compliance.' Fail to pay a fine, criticise the wrong policy or default on a loan and your details are published as a warning to others.

Add to this deep dive inspections, facial recognition, predictive policing and cross-linked databases and digital identity becomes less about convenience and more about control.

These examples show that a unified digital ID doesn’t just simplify life; it simplifies surveillance. When anonymity disappears, accountability stops being reciprocal; it flows one way, from citizen to state.

One of the laziest defences of digital ID is, “If you’ve got nothing to hide, why worry?” The answer is another question - do you have anything to hide in your home? No? Then why do you have curtains?

Privacy isn’t secrecy; it’s dignity, the right to decide who gets to look in. The danger of digital ID isn’t the convenience it offers. It’s the power it gives others to pull those curtains back whenever they choose. Make up your own mind - link - Artificial lawyer - link - More like this (ID) - link - more like this (government) - link

Tuesday, 4 November 2025

(GUF) THE SMART MONEY'S ON DUMB BINS

Every few years, a local council rediscovers a mind numbing ‘new idea’ that will revolutionise waste management. Right now, it’s - smart bins (again); metal boxes that tell you when they’re full.

Brentwood Borough Council is the latest to flirt with the fantasy; talking about kitting out their high street and an A12 lay-by with ‘intelligent’ bins fitted with sensors, Wi-Fi and a monthly software subscription - all for the modest price of up to £4,495 each - or a trial bargain at £95 a month.

The promise is that they’ll send an alert when they’re nearly full. The reality however is that they’ll send a lot of alerts when the signal gets weak, the battery dies, the lid jams shut/open, the app crashes or someone kicks the crap out of them.

This is Britain, not Silicon Valley. Our bins endure rain, grit, foxes, kebab boxes and the occasional seagull with attitude. Electronics don’t tend to thrive in that environment.

Councils like Brentwood already have collection crews driving regular routes, litter-picking and emptying along the way. Those crews have something no sensor has ever achieved - eyeballs. They can see when a bin’s full and when it’s been used as a makeshift ashtray, or worse.

The “smart” idea isn’t new. Dozens of councils have tried them. Some liked the data; most found the maintenance costs and false alerts outweighed the benefits. Several quietly went back to good old fashioned steel bins and common sense.

As one councillor said, this smells like a huge gimmick and he’s right. If this pilot happens at all, it’ll be because the supplier’s offering a free trial and someone fancies looking futuristic for the minutes. The only genuinely smart part would be to stick a QR code on every bin, let residents scan and report an overflow and save the taxpayers a few thousand quid.

Until the day a bin can dodge traffic, sweep up its own litter and pay its own Wi-Fi bill, I’d recommend we stick to the dumb and reliable. link - more like this (bins) - link - more like this (councils) - link


Monday, 3 November 2025

(GUF) HERE WE GO AGAIN


Settle in for your intro to the climate talks, including why they're important and how we can demand climate justice at the upcoming talks in Brazil - link - more like this (COP) - link

Saturday, 1 November 2025

( GUF) COUNCIL MALFEASANCE OR GOOD POLICY?


In towns and cities across the UK, environmental enforcement has quietly evolved into an industry. What began as a deterrent against fly-tipping and littering has morphed into a pay-per-fine business model; one that rewards overreach, punishes common sense and undermines public trust.

Councils are legally forbidden from using fines to raise revenue.

DEFRA’s own guidance is unambiguous: 'The purpose of fixed penalty notices is to offer an offender the opportunity to discharge liability for an offence; not to raise revenue' and yet, through outsourcing to private enforcement firms, many councils have found a convenient loophole; subcontract the punishment, pocket the proceeds and throw around the claim that 'it’s all in the name of cleaner streets'.

The illusion of legality lies in the language. Councils don’t “profit” from fines, they reinvest penalty income into enforcement operations and even put disclaimers on their websites 'to prove' it. Private contractors, in turn, are remunerated per offence successfully issued. In plain English, that's fines fund fines.

Professional, highly efficient enforcement companies now patrol public spaces across the UK operating under cost-neutral contracts that tie their *income directly to the number (and value) of fixed penalty notices (FPNs) issued 
(*the company - the enforcement officers are (apparently) paid a salary that is not determined by the number of FPNs issued according to council websites). The result is a system where enforcement success isn’t measured by cleaner streets, but instead by spreadsheet totals.

It’s a neat cycle, the contractor issues the fine, takes a share and transfers a portion to the council. The council in turn uses that income to 'support environmental services', a category conveniently vague enough to include the contract itself. This circular funding model creates a perverse incentive, more fines mean more funding mean more fines etc, and when every FPN helps justify next year’s budget, overzealous enforcement becomes not just possible, but highly profitable. It’s no coincidence that fine volumes often spike dramatically after a new private enforcement deal begins.

If this all sounds theoretical, ask the people who’ve been caught in it. A non-smoker in Manchester fined £433.00 for dropping a cigarette he never had; a Hertfordshire resident fined £500.00 because an envelope blew out of his bin; a Richmond woman fined £150.00 for pouring her coffee down a drain (later told she should’ve poured it into a litter bin instead).

It’s hard to tell which is more absurd, the enforcement itself or the excuses offered afterwards, and these aren’t isolated incidents; they’re symptoms of a system where 'environmental policing' has become performance-based revenue collection.

When challenged, councils say the fines are issued by private contractors; when pressed, the contractors insist they’re acting under the council’s direction and between them lies an accountability black hole where common sense goes to curl up and die. The Local Government Ombudsman has repeatedly criticised this blurred responsibility, noting that councils can’t outsource legal accountability, only the act of enforcement but that hasn’t stopped the industry growing.

The UK needs real environmental protection, not performative punishment. Enforcement should educate, correct and deter, not intimidate, but when compliance becomes a business model, fairness becomes optional and overreach becomes standard council policy.

Let’s be clear - this isn’t the fault of the enforcement contractors who are only doing exactly what they’ve been hired to do. The real issue lies with the councils themselves who have chosen to introduce and endorse this model. It’s a policy decision, not an accident.

It’s time to ask whether this isn’t just over-enforcement, but malfeasance: a deliberate exploitation of legal grey areas to generate revenue under the guise of regulation because enforcement has become a cash making business and the environment isn’t the one being protected, it’s the council's profit margin.

#WasteManagement #EnvironmentalPolicy #CommonSense #PublicAccountability #RichmondUponKafka - bin diving - link - more like this (litter) - link - more like this (fines) - link

Saturday, 25 October 2025

(GUF) COUNCILS LOVE LITTER


Richmond upon Thames - A woman fined £150 for pouring leftover coffee down a drain. The fine was later cancelled when the council admitted her appeal would “likely have succeeded.” The Guardian - link

Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council - Accused of “unjustified” fly-tipping fines after outsourcing enforcement to a private firm. Residents were fined for trivial or accidental acts. The Guardian - link

Hertfordshire - A man fined £500 for fly-tipping when an envelope blew out of his bin. Reduced to £100 on appeal. The Guardian - link

Manchester City Council - A non-smoker fined £433 for dropping a cigarette butt he never dropped and wasn’t even there. Conviction later overturned. The Guardian - link

Aberdeen City Council - Hired a private firm whose wardens were accused of “ambushing” residents and issuing on-the-spot fines for things like dropped receipts or wind-blown litter. The Scottish Sun - link

Medway Council - Publicly criticised after multiple prosecutions for minor waste incidents, with fines of up to £1,000 and “cost-neutral” enforcement partnerships. BBC - link

Reading Borough Council - Rolled out seven-day environmental enforcement patrols run by a private contractor, funded through fines — up to £500 for litter, £1,000 for fly-tipping. Reading.gov.uk - link - Reading Borough Council incorrectly fines - link

Bedford Borough Council - Issued heavy penalties for small-scale waste incidents, including residents fined when items were stolen from their bins and dumped elsewhere. Bedford.gov.uk - link

In UK law and government guidance, local authorities are not permitted to use enforcement powers (like fines or penalty notices) as a means of generating income.

Statutory framework

The Environmental Protection Act 1990, Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment Act 2005 and Environmental Offences (Fixed Penalties) (England) Regulations 2017 give councils the power to issue fixed penalty notices (FPNs) for littering, fly-tipping and similar offences but those same frameworks along with statutory guidance from DEFRA are explicit that penalties are intended as deterrents, not as revenue sources.

DEFRA’s 'Fixed Penalty Notices: Guidance on the Use of Penalty Receipts (England)' states: 'The purpose of fixed penalty notices is to offer an offender the opportunity to discharge liability for an offence, not to raise revenue' and 'Local authorities must not set fixed penalties at levels that are designed to raise income or to fill funding gaps.' (DEFRA Guidance, 2018 update – sections 3.3 and 3.6).

If councils do receive money from fines, the law only allows that income to be used for litter and environmental enforcement functions, or supporting related services (street cleansing, waste management, environmental education, etc.). It cannot be diverted into general funds or used as a revenue target.

The problem is that many councils outsource enforcement to private contractors who take a commission or payment per fine issued which indirectly creates a financial incentive to issue more fines even though councils themselves aren’t supposed to do so for revenue. This practice has been heavily criticised by The Manifesto Club, The Local Government Ombudsman, and MPs during the 2022 Public Accounts Committee review of enforcement contracts.

Private enforcement contracts on fine-based funding models leads to overreach, error and erosion of trust. When environmental enforcement becomes a revenue stream, justice becomes collateral. litter - link - more like this (pistonheads) - link - more like this (rubbish) - link

(GUF) RICHMOND UPON KAFKA


When in Richmond upon Thames, if you ever find yourself with a coffee, tea or any drink you just can’t finish the council advises you to pour it into a litter bin where it will mix nicely with dry material ensuring that nothing in that bin can be recycled because nothing says 'environmental enforcement' quite like creating contamination on purpose.

This followed a £150.00 fine issued to Ms Yesilyurt for tipping the remains of her coffee into a roadside drain; a fine the Council has since cancelled, admitting her appeal would 'likely have succeeded'. 

Behind this absurdity lies something darker. Many councils now outsource 'environmental policing' to private enforcement firms whose success and payment often depend on the number and value of fines issued so it’s little wonder we’re seeing scattergun enforcement using legislation written to target industrial polluters being used against people with takeaway cups.

When profit becomes the driver of compliance, common sense tends to be the first casualty.

This overextension of environmental law is becoming all too common: legislation written to tackle commercial pollution (illegal deposit of waste on land not licensed to accept it) is now being used to police everyday behaviour. It’s not enforcement; it’s embarrassment and the councils perpetuating this culture of surveillance and overreach deserve to be named, challenged, and held to account. Link - Kafka - link - more like this (litter) - link - more like this (legislation) - link

Saturday, 18 October 2025

GUF) DAILY DIETARY CARBON ALLOWANCE


There's a photograph of a sandwich doing the rounds on 'x' showing a sandwich with a label - “Eating this uses 8.1% of your daily dietary carbon allowance” .

It’s a subtle shift from informing to influencing wrapped in eco-language. That label isn’t about data, it’s about behavioural steering. It implies you have a daily carbon quota (which you don’t) and eating this sandwich is using up part of it (like sinning in grams). You should therefore feel something - guilt, virtue, restraint.

It’s not aimed at people tracking their emissions; it’s aimed at the already eco-conscious, the ones who might pause at the counter and think twice. It works by moral association, not mathematical precision and that’s the worrying bit. Food is already moralised enough through calories, fat, sugar and now this adds a new layer of worthiness. “Eat less carbon” quickly turns into “feel bad for lunch.”

Useful awareness tool? Maybe, but creeping behavioural conditioning - that's a definite. The best option for you, the planet, and Raynor's is, don't buy it, don't eat it, get a guilt ridden cheeseburger and enjoy - link - More like this - link - More like this - link - More like this (carbon) - link

Sunday, 12 October 2025

(GUF) SAF - MYTHICAL AVIATION


For years, Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) has been pitched as the saviour of air travel’s climate footprint. Politicians point to it, airlines market it and investors circle it. But scratch the surface and the maths, physics and logistics tell a different story - SAF will never scale to the percentages that really matter - never ever.

Aviation burns approximately 350 million tonnes of jet fuel every year. To make 30% of that SAF would mean producing somewhere between 100 - 110 million tonnes annually. Putting that in perspective, today, SAF contributes less than 1% of jet fuel demand.

HEFA (Hydroprocessed Esters and Fatty Acids) made from used cooking oil, tallow and vegetable oils is today’s dominant SAF pathway. It’s by far the easiest to commercialise but utterly capped by feedstock. Jet cut from HEFA equates to approximately 15 - 35% of product, so to supply 30% SAF, we’d need 300 - 700 million tonnes of waste lipids every year.

When you run HEFA through a refinery process, you don’t get 100% jet fuel out the other end. You get a slate of products including renewable diesel (HVO) (the majority product) naphtha (lighter hydrocarbons). Jet fuel range (SAF) is only a slice of the barrel, so if you put in 100 tonnes of used cooking oil, you might get 15 - 25 tonnes jet fuel (the “jet cut”). For this reason, HEFA is a side-stream supplier of SAF, not a dominant source. Even if you maxed out all global used cooking oil and fats, most of it comes out as road diesel, not jet.

Global used cooking oil supply is currently around 30 million tonnes. Add in animal fats and you still miss the target by a factor of 10.

Another source of SAF is the gasification/Fischer Tropsch route which promises jet fuel from crop residues, forestry offcuts and municipal waste. On paper it works (in practice) although the yield is around 0.1 tonne jet per tonne of dry biomass, so to hit 30% SAF you'd need around 1 billion tonnes of biomass every year; biomass that's also needed in power generation, heating, soil health and has multiple material uses.

Even if technically viable, mobilising and processing that volume sustainably is closer to fantasy than policy.

Lastly, there's the Power-to-Liquid (PtL) and the energy maths bites hard; SAF needs 23–28 kWh per litre of jet so a meaningful 30% SAF (120–130 billion litres) would need approximately 2,700 - 3,500 TWh per year which equates to about 10% of total global electricity generation in 2023.

In addition, there's the 400 million tonnes of CO₂ (estimated) to be captured and processed which ultimately means that building that scale of renewables, electrolysers, CO₂ capture and PtL plants is not a policy ambition, it’s a civilisational undertaking.

Even the EU’s bold ReFuelEU regulation only mandates 6% SAF by 2030. Current build-outs globally don’t get close to double digits. 30% is not on the map. Not in the 2030s, not in the 2040s. More like this (flying) - link - more like this (SAF) - link

Saturday, 11 October 2025

(GUF) BRITAIN'S PLASTIC INDUSTRY NEEDS PPWR


Right now, the UK’s Plastic Packaging Tax (PPT) puts a flat £210.82 per tonne (2025 rate) on plastic packaging with <30% recycled content which sounds good on paper but in practice it’s a very blunt tool.

It raises revenue but doesn’t scale supply of recycled feedstock. It punishes brands even when food contact regulations make 30% recycled impossible and it's led to paperwork gymnastics rather than packaging redesign. 

Meanwhile, the EU’s Packaging & Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) is pushing for mandatory recycled content targets by polymer & format (PET, HDPE, PP, flexibles etc.). Eco-design rules include recyclability, disassemblability, colour restrictions and label guidance and is harmonised EPR with modulated fees to reward good design.

The UK simply doesn't need a plastic tax that punishes failure. We need a plastic framework that guarantees success and should dump PPT and adopt PPWR before we see the rest of our plastic recycling industry infrastructure close down for good.

If the UK swapped its Plastic Packaging Tax for a PPWR-style 30% recycled content mandate, the impact would be transformative. Recycled HDPE use would triple to nearly 400,000* tonnes a year; LDPE would quadruple to around 350,000* tonnes and PP would explode six-fold, also to nearly 400,000* tonnes per annum. (*estimated).

PET is already close to target, but the others show the prize is not just revenue for the Treasury but real markets, real investment, and real circularity.

PPT is a stick with no carrot; it raises money but doesn’t fix the system. PPWR is system change; It aligns design, recycling capacity and recycled content demand - it creates a market. PPWR - link - More like this (PPWR) - link - more like this (EU) - link

Saturday, 4 October 2025

(GUF) TOOTHPASTE TUBE RECYCLING


I’m a cynic, my default position is “I don’t believe that" and I don’t think I’m alone. Most people, when it comes to recycling assume: “They don’t really recycle it, do they? It all just goes in the same hole in the ground.” 

Now, WRAP, the toothpaste brands and the usual recycling cheerleaders are all celebrating; toothpaste tubes are “now recyclable.” - the OPRL logos are on the packs, the adverts are running, the PR machine is humming.

But let’s not take them at their word; if toothpaste tubes are truly recyclable alongside HDPE milk and detergent bottles, then surely there’s a UK reprocessor already accepting them - which plants are actually sorting, stripping, washing and pelletising them into new plastic; where’s the video showing toothpaste tubes running down the line and coming out as useful feedstock because that’s the missing piece in this story.

The circular economy doesn’t end with a logo on the pack, it ends when those packs become new products and until we can name names and point to facilities, all we’re applauding is potential, not practice, and in recycling, potential doesn’t pay the bills or close the loop.

So show us the tubes; show us the process; show us the proof; then, and only then, we’ll celebrate with you because if no one can show evidence it’s happening, the risk is people stop believing and that’s a credibility gap our industry can’t afford. Talking Rubbish - link - more like this (recycling) - link

Saturday, 27 September 2025

(GUF) DIGITAL WASTE TRACKING


If we mix UK reality with lessons from France’s EPR roll-outs and South Korea’s Allbaro system, the idea of rolling out Digital Waste Tracking over the next couple of years in the UK is laughable. Infact, not even this decade - the honesty being that cradle to grave coverage is a 2030s project.

With no receiving data until late 2025, any IT project of this size will then need at least 12-18 months of live bedding-in before phase 2 (carriers/brokers) which currently has no date and is subject to funding and review in September 2025. DEFRA has only promised 'a decision' in 2025, not a start date.

The earliest realistic law-making window is around 2027, which means mandatory use couldn’t begin before late 2028 or 2029 and that’s if everything goes flawlessly. Phase 3 (producers and full cradle-to-grave coverage) would still need new secondary legislation and a national behaviour-change campaign, with no formal commitment yet in place.

There are a couple of International benchmarks - France (EPR + TrackDéchets) - pilot work started 2018; hazardous waste tracking went live 2021; full sector coverage is still expanding in 2024–25. It took roughly 6 - 7 years from pilot to broad mandatory coverage.

South Korea (Allbaro) - announced mid-1990s; national hazardous & municipal tracking fully embedded by early 2000s, it took approximately 10 years from concept to near-total cradle-to-grave reporting. Both countries had stronger centralised governance and more consistent funding than the UK typically musters.

The UK has an appalling track record when it comes to implementation of waste and sustainability legislation. Extended Producer Responsibility (packaging) slipped from 2023 → 2025+ (and still not fully operational). The Deposit Return Scheme has bounced through four separate target years. Digital Waste Tracking itself has already moved from 'April 2025' to 'April 2026 service / Oct 2026 mandate'.

A two year delay is practically built into every big environmental IT policy. Plausible UK rollout pathway (realistic, not optimistic).

If everything ran like a German train, maybe 2029. If it runs like a typical UK waste policy (think Simpler Recycling or DRS) expect early 2030s for true  'everyone in the chain' coverage. That’s not pessimism, just pattern recognition - big IT + fragmented industry + shifting governments = slow, stop-start progress. 

So the smart money is on Phase 1 bedding-in through the late 2020s and full cradle-to-grave tracking no earlier than the next Parliament after 2030. More like this (electronic tagging) - link - more like this (Allbaro) - link 

Sunday, 21 September 2025

(GUF) EU LEGISLATION


EU environmental law is built like a cathedral; many architects, countless masons, trades and an army of inspectors.

Each new directive draws on 27 member states’ ministries, civil-service teams, scientific committees, the European Environment Agency, Parliament committees, industry bodies, NGOs and public consultations in every language. The result is legislation that’s broad, stress-tested, and difficult to pick apart because it’s been hammered into shape by thousands of contributors.

By contrast, the UK process is currently more like a well-meaning garden shed project: a handful of Whitehall departments and Westminster committees, fewer expert layers and far smaller stakeholder input. It can (in theory) move quicker but the trade off is reach and resilience; policies risk being narrower, easier to lobby, less future-proof or repeatedly kicked down the road.

EU waste, reuse, and circular-economy measures typically arrive more robust, all-encompassing and precisely defined than their UK counterparts. When more minds build the framework, the structure stands stronger and to dismiss that body of work on grounds of geography alone isn’t sovereignty, it’s self-sabotage.

The environment doesn’t stop at Dover and neither should our policy.
Adopting EU waste and circular economy legislation isn’t about waving a blue flag; it’s about cost, access and timing. EU legislation 1 - link - EU legislation 2 - link - more like this - link

Sunday, 14 September 2025

(GUF) LITTLE BOTTLES

Well done to South Australia for banning those little plastic soy fish that swim straight from sushi trays into landfill but the EU is going even further.

Across the EU, hotels supply approximately 10 billion single-use hotel mini-toiletries (those 30 ml shampoo and body-wash bottles) annually; in addition, food service supplies around 40 billion single-use condiment sachets (ketchup, mayo, sauce, etc) a year, most unrecyclable multi-layer films and the EU Packaging & Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) is finally coming for the industry’s most convenient inconvenience.

Article 22 & Annex V targets single-use packaging for consumables used in the hospitality and food service sectors that can be reasonably replaced by reusable or refillable systems. Reuse systems (wall dispensers, pump bottles, refill stations) are documented to reduce waste by up to 90% per guest. It’s a clear signal that design-for-reuse is no longer optional.

With the ban taking effect gradually from 2030 (final Parliament text currently points to a 2030 full prohibition with some earlier targets for reuse roll-out), exemptions exist only if no hygiene-safe refill or reusable system exists.

The ban covers hotels, cruise lines, airlines, hostels, fast food, takeaways, event caterers, all brand owners & importers supplying the EU market (even UK exporters). Even if the UK diverges post-Brexit, exporters to the EU will need PPWR-compliant refill formats.

A big pat on the back for the EU is due (could be sooner) and a big wake up call to the UK is needed - there is no UK law exactly like the PPWR’s ban on mini toiletries & sachets ready (as far as I'm aware). PPWR - link - more like this - link

Saturday, 6 September 2025

(GUF) BAEKELAND'S FOLLY

Outside of PET bottles and the odd bit of HDPE, recycling is smoke, mirrors and a big fat lucrative oil pipeline. Geneva proved just how divided things are; the EU, several African states and a Latin American coalition pushed for binding caps on virgin polymer whilst the US, China and petro-states cling to the stupid fantasy that recycling alone will save us.

When your flagship recyclers across the globe are openly admitting 'this isn’t viable at scale', you’d expect urgency to swing towards cutting output; instead, negotiators are being fed an escape hatch: 'if mechanical doesn’t work, maybe chemical recycling will save the day' - (spoiler alert) that's not a plan, that’s a stalling tactic.

Every tonne that isn’t recycled is a guaranteed sale of virgin resin and as long as oil stays cheap, petrochemical majors are laughing. They wrap it up in noble PR terms 'essential plastics' for health, food security, medicine etc while their social media pimps pump out sermons on the life-saving wonders of single-use. The hard truth is that 70–80% of plastics are functionally unrecyclable and when the treaty finally accepts that, maybe urgency could finally shift toward upstream measures; caps on virgin polymer, bans on design-for-waste formats and phase-outs of the worst offenders because if it dodges again, expect another decade of voluntary pledges 🥱 glossy PowerPoints and deeper fossil lock-in.

The oil industry hasn’t 'won' yet, but they’re playing the long game and every year of delay is another victory. The treaty could still matter hugely but only when the negotiators admit that they're treating lung cancer with cough syrup.

Designing and manufacturing a material with no end-of-life solution isn’t innovation, it’s selfish, cynical, and irresponsible. If companies are going to profit from plastics, they need to do one of two things - restrict production to polymers with a proven recycling route or pay directly for their destruction through incineration not by hiding behind some wreck of a convoluted EPR scheme.

Kicking the can down the road has kept producers comfortable since Leo Baekeland came up with Bakelite in 1907 but it’s buried the real cost in everyone else’s lap. If “circular economy” is to mean anything, it has to start with stopping the flow of materials that never had a chance of being circular in the first place. More like this (plastics) - link - they knew it was lies - link